Skip to main content

Why are some people against the death penalty? - Part 2

Welcome to the Part 2 of "Why are some people against the death penalty?"

Today, I am going to explain the details of these opinions. 

1. There is racial and economic discrimination in application of the death penalty.
2. Application of the death penalty tends to be arbitrary and capricious. Many cases are biased.
3. The death penalty involves medical doctors, who are supposed to preserve life. But they have to be involved in the act of killing.
4.There are many religious reasons for some people to oppose the death penalty.



1. There is racial and economin discrimination in application of the death penalty.
→ Many convicted criminals are biased. All five of the prisoners executed since 1977—one shot, one gassed and three electrocuted—were white. This looks like a morbid kind of affirmative action plan, making up for past discrimination against blacks. But the five were not representative of the death-row population, except in being male. About 99 percent of the death-row inmates are men.

Black persons in Florida who commit murder, "those who kill whites are nearly 40 times more likely to be sentenced to death than those who kill blacks. (Crime & Delinquency, 1980)"


2. Application of the death penalty tends to be arbiterary and capricious.
→  For example, for similar crimes, some people are sentenced while others were not. Furthermore, there are many cases that innocent people got executed due to the arbiterary judge or inaduquate research for complicated cases. Once a person's life is taken away, there is not way to compensate it. So why support the system?


3. The death penalty involves medical doctors who are supposed to preserve life. But they have to be involved in the act of killing. 
→ The death penalty involves medical doctors, for example, when the country uses lethal injections for execution. Doctors who are supposed to save lives have to be involved in killing.

4. There are many religious reasons for some people to oppose the death penalty.
→ One of the men who answered to the question which was asked by the writer of thie article, said "that Christ would oppose the killing of a human being as punishment for a crime." This view is supported by the New Testament story about the woman who faced execution by stoning (John 8:7, "He that is without sin among you, let him cast the first stone").  Furthermore, Japan and USA are the only countries that hold democracy. If freedom of belief is guaranteed, why do these countries still have such a system that opposes their ideas? Why such rights are not guaranteed?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Death Penalty from 3 perspectives

  P erspective 1. murder victim's family who is against death penalty HI, I am the mother of Julie Heath. The last time anyone saw our daughter, Julie Heath alive was Oct. 3, 1993. She was 18-year-old and set out to visit her boyfriend in Hot Springs, Arkansas. A week later, a hunter discovered Heath’s body, less than eight miles from where her broken-down car was found. She wore a black shirt, socks and underwear, but they were inside-out. Her black jeans were partially unzipped. Her throat was slashed. Police later arrested Eric Randall Nance for Heath’s murder. Investigators said he picked her up near her vehicle, before DNA evidence proved he raped and killed her. In 1994, he was handed the death penalty.  But even when executions take place, the pain of surviving family like us doesn’t disappear with the perpetrator’s pulse. Death penalty advocates and politicians, including Arkansas Attorney General Leslie Rutledge, argue that when the state executes a person who has com...
1 comment
Read more

Death Penalty in ancient times

Capital punishment actually has a longer history than people imagine. Historical records show that people in the most ancient times even utilized methods of punishing criminals or wrongdoers.   “A life for a life” has been one of the most basic concepts for dealing with crime since the start of recorded history"(crime museum, 2021). Today, I am going to introduce some of the early forms of capital punishment and examples. Early forms of death penalty was made to punish the criminal slowly, so the person can feel the pain until they breath their last. Types of tourtures were different depending on what kind of crime they committed. For examples, law breakers were " put to death by stoning, crucifixion, being burned at the stake, and even slowly being crushed by elephants"(crime museum, 2021). Some other methods in the ancient times were, bites by snakes, devouring by animals, tearing apart by animals and trampling by horses. Later, the soceities started to realize that th...
2 comments
Read more

Interview with Mary Stennett Sellers, Mother of Death Row Inmate - pt.2

- Wrongful conviction - Threats were not only through messages but also someone has shot the car once Matt has driven and another one was attempting to break in their house. Not only the convicted person but also their family's life changes too. They had to sell the house and move away. She also talks about the sadness and ignorance of people7s atittude towards internet that they could be so careless about hurting someone. Was there every a time where you doubted Matt’s innocence? Can you tell us why or why not? She said that she knew the very second that I heard about he was not involved in such a crime, but at the same time, there were some thoughts made her confused and emotional. Later, they had a private visit with Matt, he told them what happened on the day, there were many truth and facts which could reainforce his innocence. Why do you want the death penalty to be ended? A civilized country which is the place we are supposed to be living - she says. Nobody has rights to tak...
Post a Comment
Read more